The first mushroom is growing strong. It's still pretty small but has increased in size by about 750% in 24 hours (that's a rough estimate).
The strange thing is that it's coming in upside down! I have read that you need to position the cake with the same vertical orientation as it was when the mycelium was forming. Perhaps we have it upside down?
We'll continue to observe and if other mushrooms grow upside down we'll flip the cake.